One of tastytrade's top ten Pillars of trading emphasizesrelative to 1 SD moves and taking advantage of the historical relationship by selling 1 SD Strangles, but is it the same relationship in 2 SD Strangles? Do the mechanics apply for ETFs as well as cash-settled indices?1SD vs 2SD Strangles
Using SPY, IWM, SPX, and RUT from 2005 to present, the Research Team sold the 1Strangle (16 Delta) in SPY and IWM, and sold the 2 SD Strangle (or 2.5 Delta) in SPX and RUT with 45 . All trades were managed at 50% of max profit if possible.
The number of trades with a winning percentage in SPX and RUT (as well as the average p/l for each) trade was high, but the few losses that occurred were large, which traders in smaller accounts should be aware of.2SD Moves & High SKEW
With 2 SD options, the high SKEW readings imply greater tail risk due to the options being bid up. Still, high SKEW levels also result in more consistent profits (see slides for more details).
Tom and Tony concluded that although they like 1 SD Strangles in underlyings like SPY, opportunities to trade 2 SD strangles in larger underlyings like SPX or RUT (though they are not a guaranteed "win") can be attractive. Ultimately, though, traders must remain cautious to the size of indices like SPX and RUT as the potential large losses they tend to witness when the market incurs large moves.